Weekend Market Commentary: When Trends Turn Into Whipsaws

One of the more legitimate reasons I started trading options is that I wanted the ability to adapt to changes in the market by adjusting positions.  In other words, I wanted to avoid hoping trades would work or simply exiting when the didn’t immediately work. February has been a challenging month for trading options, but that has everything to do with wide ranges and whipsaws rather than trends.

The reality of the market is that price can have significant moves in one direction (the primary trend) with strong moves in the opposite direction (counter or shorter term trend). At the same time, the market can be bound by ranges or balances where price advances and declines without follow through to the frustration of directional participants. Saying we’re bullish or bearish is completely meaningless without timeframes to create context.

The media generally focuses on whatever happened today. In most cases, that means a green candle is bullish and a red candle is bearish. The only context is “right now” and price is used as a vehicle to drive emotions. While that simplicity might be acceptable for unsuccessful traders/investors looking for entertainment in the markets, it doesn’t create the context necessary for success.

If we think about the market as being like a natural system, the themes we see are similar to the weather. In the fall, temperatures slowly start to decrease as winter approaches. At the same time, there can be warm weeks and months that make it seem like winter might be mild or won’t arrive. The warm spring like weather on the East Coast around the holidays in 2015 is the perfect example. However, eventually winter arrives and even a mild winter won’t be as warm as the summer.

What we’re seeing in the markets right now could be like a warm week in the fall or early winter. Sure, the markets had a solid rally in the past week or so, but the bigger picture hasn’t changed significantly. On the weekly and daily timeframes we see price trading in a wide range. In that sense, the market is simply ranging, rather than declining, at the moment.

When we’re in the middle of trading, it’s easy to get caught up in the emotions of what’s happening “right now,” but we need to step back and look at our positions in the context of the market. As non-directional traders that means we simply move our positions when they aren’t working.

The market doesn’t exist to validate levels we think are important and the only way to survive is to control risk while maintaining a sense of context while trading options. Right now the short term signals are mixed while the longer term theme remains weak.


Volatility continues to be a great confirming indicator in 2016. Last week we saw a divergence in the VIX:VXV ratio that was validated this week. We also saw a drop in implied volatility that preceded the Implied Volatility (IV) collapse this week. If volatility is right, the market has the potential to move higher in the short term.

Even though Implied Volatility is under control, elevated Historical Volatility in the S&P 500 and especially the Russell 2000 is reason for concern. Historical Volatility (HV) on the Russell 2000 is trading higher than last August following the mini-crash. At the same time, Implied Volatility is trading at a discount to 20 day Historical Volatility. Generally IV falling below 20 Day HV is somewhat bullish, but the elevated level of HV is a little troubling and makes me wonder if the recent short covering rally will fail. I’ll have more confidence in the potential for higher prices if Historical Volatility begins to decline.

stock market realized volatility chart february 22

sp 500 index stock market chart with vix vxv volatility ratio february

russell 2000 implied volatility chart february 22

The VIX Futures term structure returned to Contango, which validates the move higher this week, but the curve is relatively flat and still subject to scrutiny. As an analogy, think about price closing above a declining long term moving average. Even though a close above a long term average is somewhat bullish, the direction of the moving average is reason for concern. Even though Contango is “healthy,” a flat curve in a broken market doesn’t inspire the same level of confidence as a steeper curve in a healthy market. Something to keep in mind when trading options.

vix term structure february 22

Market Stats

stock market indices performance february

Levels Of Interest

In the levels of interest section, we’ll look at the daily chart of the S&P 500 Index and Russell 2000 Index and identify some levels to keep in mind when trading options during the week ahead.

sp 500 index chart price support levels february 22

russell 2000 index stock chart price resistance levels february 22

Thanks for reading and good luck in the week ahead.


Twitter: @ThetaTrend

Author holds positions in S&P 500 and Russell 2000 related securities at the time of publication. Any opinions expressed herein are solely those of the author, and do not in any way represent the views or opinions of any other person or entity.


Sign up for our FREE newsletter
and receive our best trading ideas and research