COT Report: Traders Make Moves In Equities And Treasuries

The following is a recap of The COT Report (Commitment Of Traders) released by the CFTC (Commodity Futures Trading Commission) looking at futures positions of non-commercial holdings as of May 5, 2015. Note that the change is week-over-week.

10-Year Note: It would be an understatement to say that this was a weird week. In the early part of the week, 10-Year Yields (TNX) were up as much as 20 basis points. Treasuries on the long end were getting “routed.” Come Thursday, bids started coming in. Even Friday’s supposedly “good” jobs report was not enough to motivate sellers. In the end, the 10-year essentially treaded water for the week.

The real rout was taking place somewhere else, though. German 10-year bunds were yielding 0.05 percent just two weeks ago, now they are at 0.54 percent – these bonds were yielding 40 basis points when eurozone QE began. Mr. Draghi is probably not thrilled.

Having said that, investor reaction to eurozone QE is not without precedent. Leading up to all three iterations of QE in the U.S. (November 2008, November 2010, and September 2012), long rates fell before rising as QE got underway. Appears to be simple front-running. Or buy the rumor, sell the news.

Sign up for our FREE newsletter
and receive our best trading ideas and research

Interestingly, non-commercials raised net shorts to a 17-week high in the recent COT Report.

Their holdings are as of Tuesday, and by then the yield had risen for seven consecutive sessions. Probably got carried away, and may very well be setting up for a squeeze.

Currently net short 183.1k, up 84.6k.

cot report 10 year treasury futures net longs may 5 2015

30-Year Bond: Despite the selling that was going on in bonds, the 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF (TLT) was beginning to attract bids as early as Tuesday, as it produced a hammer near its 200-day moving average, where it closed out the week. The TLT looks constructively positioned to move higher; 122 support is key, and 127 gap resistance lies ahead. As a corollary, the 30-year yield found support at its 200-day moving average, but remains way overbought on a daily basis.

The one data point that can throw a monkey wrench into this scenario is retail sales for April that comes out on Wednesday. This series has had a rough go of it in recent months. Four out of the past seven months, sales shrank month-over-month (March was up 0.9 percent). Year-over-year growth decelerated to 1.3 percent in March from five percent last August.

NFIB small business optimism index and JOLTS are out on Tuesday. The latter only goes back to 2004, but job openings have tended to lead non-farm payrolls. February saw an all-time high of 5.1 million openings; in contrast, quits weakened to 2.7 million, so this needs to be watched closely.

Industrial production is out on Friday. Capacity utilization posted a cycle high 79.5 last December, and has since dropped to 78.4 (March). This kind of rhymes with what is going on in the global economy. In China, both foreign and domestic demand has softened going into 2Q. In April, both exports and imports fell 6.4 percent and 16.2 percent, respectively; they were also down 15 percent and 12.7 percent in March.

Currently net long 11k, up 7.5k.

cot report bonds futures net longs may 5 2015

Crude oil: The EIA reported that U.S. crude stocks fell last week for the first time since the week ended January 2; inventories dropped by 3.88 million barrels. At one point, spot West Texas Intermediate crude was up nearly $3 for the week, but gave it all away.

That price action created a shooting star on the weekly chart (as well as one on Wednesday). This is a strong signal that we may have a top in oil prices – near-term probable, intermediate-term possible. EOG, by the way, made it very clear that it plans to return to double-digit production growth should the WTI reach $65 or higher. It is an automatic price cap, come to think of it.

On Friday, support at 58 was successfully tested. But a bigger test probably lies ahead; 54 is a must-hold.

Note this little nugget from an April 10th Fitch Ratings survey of 75 senior investors: Sixty one percent of respondents said high-yield bonds are modestly or strongly overvalued. Fitch also said credit conditions are worsening in the energy sector, which is 18 percent of high-yield bonds. The energy default rate is rising – 0.9 percent at end-March.

Currently net long 348.1k, up 4.5k.

cot report crude oil futures net long may 5 2015

E-mini S&P 500: Did buybacks begin in earnest already? You wonder! In the first three sessions this week, the S&P 500 large cap index was down nearly two percent. By Friday, it was all recouped, and then some. FactSet points out that $13 billion came out of SPY in April. So corporations better keep their buyback machine humming along.

Even Janet Yellen, Federal Reserve chair, is beginning to talk about valuations! Not that multiples are crazy high, but they are above average. In a panel discussion on Wednesday, she opined: “I guess I would highlight that equity valuations at this point generally are quite high. They are not so high when you compare the returns on equities to the returns on safe assets like bonds, which are also very low but there are potential dangers there.” Equities give her the cold shoulder. Ah, well!  So much for ‘don’t fight the Fed’.

There was whipsaw action all week. It is possible non-commercials became a victim themselves. The index dropped 1.2 percent on Tuesday, which perhaps led them to increase net shorts – by 129 percent in the reporting week (according to COT Report data). They probably got squeezed on Friday.

Currently net short 79.3k, up 44.7k.

cot report sp 500 net short may 5 2015

Euro: In keeping with whipsaw actions in various other assets this week, the currency markets also had its share. The Euro was up 1.6 percent into Wednesday, only to give it all back by the end of the week.

Not surprising perhaps given that the currency rallied nearly nine percent from trough to peak over the past seven weeks. Along the way, some good news came along. The European Commission now expects the euro area economy to grow 1.5 percent this year, up from previous forecast of 1.3 percent.

Nonetheless, it is probably time for a breather. On a weekly basis, oversold conditions still have unwinding left to do. But daily conditions are now way overbought, and look ready to head lower. The 50-day moving average lies at 108.74.

From the March-end highs, non-commercials have reduced net shorts by 16 percent according to the COT Report.

Currently net short 190.1k, down 7.6k.

cot report euro futures net short may 5 2015

Gold: The sideways move in Gold is probably beginning to get on these traders’ nerves. They reduced net longs by 28 percent, which are now down substantially from end-January highs. Gold cannot get going.

If there is any comfort in this sideways action, it is this: The moving averages are consolidating as well. Several short-term moving averages are no longer pointing down. And the Bollinger bands are narrowing as well. A sharp jolt may be upon us sooner than later, notwithstanding the direction. The weekly MACD that was earlier decidedly pointing down is kind of flattish now.

Currently net long 72.4k, down 28.8k.

cot report gold futures net longs lowest may 5 2015

Nasdaq 100 index (mini): On Monday, the Nasdaq tried to take out the 4480 level but could not get the job done. Even after the Friday rally, it is still under that resistance. The good thing is, buyers showed up near 4340 support on Wednesday. On the PowerShares Nasdaq 100 ETF (QQQ) this level corresponds to 106 (give and take). The 4480 level corresponds to 109 on the QQQ, which it is currently under. This is the hurdle bulls need to jump over.

Not sure if there is any message in non-commercials cutting back net longs in the recent COT Report. This is their first reduction in five weeks.

Currently net long 66.9k, down 21.5k.

cot report nasdaq 100 net longs may 5 2015

Russell 2000 mini-index: Since 1Q15 GDP print on Wednesday morning last week, the Russell 2000 (RUT) has lost nearly two percent; in contrast, the S&P 500 is essentially flat.

Up until now, the argument for owning small-caps was: (1) large-caps were getting hurt by a surging dollar, and (2) the U.S. economy was outperforming. 1Q put that to end – or at least helped sow the seeds of doubt.

This is beginning to get reflected in investor behavior.

Non-commercials have raised net shorts to an eight-week high. Post-jobs report on Friday, small-caps underperformed their larger brethren by a substantial margin.

The good thing, if you are bullish small-caps, is that the 1215 level has been saved for now. As a reminder, the RUT broke the mid-October trendline last week.

Currently net short 26.7k, up 21.2k.

cot report russell 2000 net shorts may 5 2015

U.S. Dollar Index: On a daily chart, there was one test of the 96 level (support turned into resistance), and that failed. Non-commercials have been cutting back net longs – now down 27 percent from the all-time high of 81.3k contracts early March. Macro data will need to improve fast to turn this trend around.

After the Jobs Report on Friday the dollar looked confused; it vacillated all day. Yes, the unemployment rate dipped to 5.4 percent (and it is not all due to healthy reasons), but April was the third month in a row that saw a downward revision of the prior month. Wages were disappointing once again.

Currently net long 58.9k, down 5.7k.

cot report us dollar futures net long may 5 2015

VIX: The good: for five months now, the spot VIX has not broken 12. It closed at 12.86 on Friday, down a whopping 15 percent. The bad: for the fourth time in the past month, an attempt to rally past 15 has been rejected. And the ugly: non-commercials increased net shorts to an 11-month high, according to this week’s COT Report data. They are going head-to-head with their peers betting on a down SPX. Only one will be right.

Currently net short 75.8k, up 7.1k.

cot report vix futures net long may 5 2015

Thanks for reading.


     Follow Paban On Twitter:  @hedgopia

     Read more from Paban on his blog.

No position in any of the mentioned securities at the time of publication. Any opinions expressed herein are solely those of the author, and do not in any way represent the views or opinions of any other person or entity.