How Is This Market Like the Tech Bubble? Margin Debt.

NYSE Margin debt, net worth, all time highEarlier this afternoon we noted Margin debt struck an all-time-high in April – and that the market’s net worth is plumbing levels last seen at the stupefying heights of the Tech Bubble.

So far, that hasn’t changed since publication; but the chart we included there from Doug Short has.

Here then is the updated chart showing nominal (i.e. not inflation-adjusted) NYSE Margin Debt and net worth (-$105.885B in April) overlaid with the S&P 500 (SPX):

Margin Debt, Net worth, All time high

Sign up for our FREE newsletter
and receive our best trading ideas and research

To Doug’s credit, there’s no better chart out there encapsulating these relationships. The return to Tech Bubble-era negative net worth I mentioned previously is on vivid display here. Doug also makes a few important notes in his accompanying comments (along with inflation-adjusted margin debt charts of the headline measure well-worth checking out), listed here in my own words:

  • Margin Debt is a leading indicator, but it is published on a lagging basis (for example, April’s data was published today).
  • Extreme negative net worth readings (2000, 2007, and 2011) have preceded market tops by at least a couple months.
  • The number of peak/trough occurrences in the series shown is too small to reliably issue a “definitive warning for US equities”.

As a result, this data has strategic (think medium and long-term) relevance and application (e.g. can be used in conjunction with sector rotation analysis, cycle analysis or formulating a longer-dated risk-defined options strategy). We benefit from keeping an eye on this measure (as we do with any other sentiment reading) by using it to keep up with a context that is rarely a the binary stuff of soundbites, but shifting risk-adjusted shades of gray in-between. Right now, those shades are darkening, as they have before: in each case in an environment when “it makes great sense to borrow”. As Doug concludes, then: ” We’ll want to keep an eye on this metric over the next few months”.