Why Wall Street’s S&P 500 Price Forecasts Don’t Add Up

As we dig through several 2017 S&P 500 price forecasts, we discover that a majority of “Wall Street’s top strategists” are calling for a year-end S&P 500 price in the 2,300-2,450 range.

None of the forecasters expect a down year for the S&P 500 Index (INDEXSP:.INX), but that’s an article for another day.

Not surprisingly, a year-end index price within the range of the aforementioned 2017 S&P 500 price forecasts would put growth in line with that experienced since 2012. While the strategists will claim they have extensive multi-factor models that help them arrive at their estimate, it is quite likely many of them rely on extrapolating prior price performance into the future based on the dangerous assumption that the future will be like the past.

Such a forecasting strategy may seem logical, and has worked well for the last four years, but it fails to acknowledge that earnings growth, which have repeatedly been grossly over-estimated, have been relatively flat over the same period. Since 2012, the S&P 500 has risen almost 70% while earnings are up a mere 2%. The graph below plots the S&P 500, earnings per share and their respective trend lines.

Sign up for our FREE newsletter
and receive our best trading ideas and research



s&p 500 performance vs earnings per share years 2012 to 2017

When price increases are not accompanied by earnings increases, it indicates that multiple expansion has occurred. In other words, the ratio of price-to-earnings (P/E) is expanding almost entirely because of its numerator- price increases.

About those 2017 S&P 500 Price Forecasts…

Whether or not an observed expansion of the P/E multiple makes sense depends upon the context. Such a situation may be justified when valuations are at or below the long run average, but keep in mind that current valuations are at levels that have rarely been eclipsed in history. The current P/E multiple is not just above average, it is 70% above the average of over 130 years of observations. For those that follow the consensus expectations, we suggest that you also extrapolate expected returns for ever increasing valuations. The graph below plots the S&P 500 and expected ten-year annualized returns. The expected return is calculated from the regression of monthly Cyclically Adjusted Price to Earnings ratio (CAPE) and the associated annualized returns that occurred over the following ten years. The data encompasses 130 years’ worth of data.

s&p 500 vs expected stock market returns chart year 2017

It is plausible that earnings will increase at a healthy clip and valuations will normalize. However, if we are to extrapolate prices like the so-called experts, then to be consistent, that same logic should also be applied to earnings and expected returns. Expected returns, having trended lower since 2012, are now forecasting a sub-1.00% annualized return for the next ten years.

This brief note is a simple reminder that extrapolating price without considering future earnings trends and valuations is a fool’s game. Extrapolating the past is relatively harmless for street prognosticators. Basing an investment strategy on such a plan, however, can have severe financial repercussions.

Thanks for reading.

Thanks for reading. Gather more unique insights by visiting our website 720Global.

 

Twitter:  @michaellebowitz

Any opinions expressed herein are solely those of the author, and do not in any way represent the views or opinions of any other person or entity.