Dow Jones 20000? Not As Important As This Stock Index

An approaching level in a lesser-known stock market index is, in our view, much more consequential than the widely anticipated Dow Jones 20000 mark.

With the Dow Jones Industrial Average (INDEXDJX:.DJI) nearing the 20000 level, anticipation on the street has become palpable. At our firm, we’ve been putting in late nights all week, fielding calls from anxious clients. If you’re picking up on sarcasm, it’s because I’m laying it on pretty thick. The big, round Dow Jones 20000 number means very little to us from an investment-decision standpoint. There is another, lesser-known index, however, that is approaching a level of major significance, in our view.

The Value Line Geometric Composite (INDEXNYSEGIS:VALUG), as we have explained many times in these pages, is an unweighted average that tracks the median stock performance among a universe of approximately 1800 stocks. Thus, in our view, it serves as perhaps the best representation of the true state of the U.S. equity market. Additionally, it has historically been very true to technical analysis and charting techniques, which is quite remarkable considering there are no tradeable vehicles based on it. And, as noted, the Value Line Geometric (VLG) is testing a monumental resistance level at the moment, going back several decades.

In 1998, the VLG topped out just north of 500 before getting cut in half over the next 4 years. In 2007, the index once again climbed back over the 500 level. It subsequently again over the next two years – this time by 70%. After a five year rally, the VLG finally made it back to the 500 level again, as we noted back in July 2014. For a third time, the index was rejected at that level dropping hard into the fall of 2014. Finally, in the spring of 2015 the Value Line Geometric Composite was able to surpass the peaks just above 500, rallying as high as 523 in April 2015. The rally proved short-lived however, as the index proceeded to lose nearly 30% over the next 10 months.

Sign up for our FREE newsletter
and receive our best trading ideas and research

Candidly, it was our view that that false breakout marked the final blow to the post 2009 cyclical bull market. As such, we expected any subsequent bounce to be a mere bear market rally, falling far short of the previous 3-decade peaks. Up until the election, that notion still appeared on track, as the post-February rally in the VLG fell some 6% shy of its previous highs, even as the large-cap stock market indices went to new highs. The “Trump Rally” has forced us to re-think that view, however.

That’s because the VLG has shot up some 14% since election day and has now arrived in the vicinity of its former highs once again.


The Value Line Geometric Composite may well struggle initially at these levels, as it always has. And, as always, we advise against “anticipating the breakout”. However, this may be the VLG’s best chance yet to break this massive 3-decade price resistance. The fact that it avoided a catastrophic selloff (e.g., 1998-2002, 2007-2009) this time before managing to return to its peaks suggests a higher level of demand (cup-&-handle?).

Should the VLG succeed in breaking decisively above its former peaks, its significance probably cannot be overstated. This would be an extremely broad market gauge braking out above 18-year, triple top peaks to new all-time highs. The short-term, and quite possibly long-term, ramifications could be exceedingly bullish.

That is why this 520-ish level in the Value Line Geometric Composite is the key level for investors to watch, in our view – even if no one has made up hats to commemorate it.

Thanks for reading.


Twitter:  @JLyonsFundMgmt

The author does not have a position in mentioned securities at the time of publication.  Any opinions expressed herein are solely those of the author, and do not in any way represent the views or opinions of any other person or entity.